Reader’s Choice Awards: Who Rises To The Call?

Vibration Versus Bearing Life
August 28, 2018
The Right Lubricant For The Right Job Helps Lower Machine Operating Costs
August 28, 2018

Reader’s Choice Awards: Who Rises To The Call?

Chemical Processing

Readers' Choice Awards

More technology providers than ever before were identified by readers of Chemical Processing in the 2009 Readers’ Choice Awards survey. That’s because the survey garnered the highest number of respondents (975) in its now six-year history.

Our readers told us which providers they consider to be technology leaders in 44 categories.

Picking a single leader probably proved tough for some readers. The survey caused another reader to reflect upon his career. “Some of the categories made me realize how long I have been in this business,” he says.

The Elastomers category in this year’s survey deserves a bit of explanation because some readers selected DuPont Dow as their choice. However, the joint venture of those companies was dissolved a couple of years ago, so we evenly distributed the totals for DuPont Dow between the two.

Making the list is important to vendors as it shows them that their technology is highly regarded by end users. Other vendors, who did not make the list, can use the information to further develop their products so that they may become your choice in the future.

BY THE NUMBERS

Emerson Process Management continued the strong showing it’s had over the years, coming in first in seven categories and placing in three others. Emerson also garnered the most comments when respondents were asked to identify one technology provider as the best and explain why. “Emerson Process Systems is the best becausue they are always bringing the most up-to-date products to market. They also provide excellent customer support,” says one respondent, which echoes the views of others.

Other vendors who earned multiple mentions include Alfa Laval, Fluke and Siemens, each with two first place finishes. ABB, Endress+Hauser, Honeywell and Rockwell Automation all placed highly in multiple categories.

If you desire additional information about any of the vendors or products listed, we encourage you to visit www.chemicalprocessing.com and search for bearings, pumps or any other category that interests you.

HOW RESULTS WERE GATHERED

Readers received e-mail notices and electronic newsletters or used a link posted on our Web site to complete the questionnaire. The survey was open for responses for just over one month. A total of 975 readers cast their votes about which vendors they consider technology leaders in 44 different categories. Categories were listed, but respondents had to enter the name of the technology provider in a blank text box. By not providing a pre-selected list of companies in each category, the survey avoided bias.

The rankings show the percentage of total responses in each category that a particular company received. A minimum of at least 5% of the votes in a category is required to be listed. Scores within 3% of each other should be considered a statistical tie.Some attempts to make lubricant upgrade decisions are based solely on comparative ASTM test results on various oil candidates. While ASTM tests can be indicators of how oil may perform, there is only one final arbiter for performance — the equipment being lubricated. Observed changes in oil and bearing temperatures, bearing vibration levels, energy demand, oil life and re-lubrication intervals, equipment cleanliness, how the oil handles water and other contaminants, and machine repair frequency and costs are all indicators of lubricant performance. There simply is no substitute for running the candidate oil upgrade in the equipment. When considering a lubricant upgrade, a competent lubricant supplier should be able to provide you with real-world case histories that will indicate whether the candidate lubricant is likely to deliver the targeted results.

Bearings

SKF 32%

Timken 16%

Motion Industries 6%


Boilers/Steam Systems

Cleaver Brooks 21%

Babcock & Wilcox 15%


Catalysts

BASF 18%

Sud-Chemie 9%

Johnson Matthey 8%

UOP 7%

Criterion 6%


Centrifugal Pumps

Goulds 38%

Flowserve 20%


Centrifuges

Alfa Laval 20%

Wesfalia 11%

Bird Machine 8%

Heinkel 6%

Kraus Maffei 6%


Compressors

Ingersol Rand 33%

Atlas Copco 15%Sullair 5%


Computerized Maintenance Management Software (CMMS)

Maximo 22%

SAP 19%

Emerson Process Management 6%


Cooling Towers

Marley 51%

BAC 10%

Delta 5%


Distillation Equipment

Koch-Glitsch 50%

Sulzer 13%


Dryers

GEA Niro 18%


Dust-Control Systems

Donaldson-Torit 32%

Micropul 7%

Flex-Kleen 5%


Elastomers

DuPont 41%

Dow 12%

Engineering/Design Services

Jacobs Engineering 12%

Fluor 7%

CH2M Hill 5%


Explosion Protection Systems

Fike 35%

Fenwal 24%


Fans & Blowers

New York Blower 29%

Howden-Buffalo 9%

Dresser Roots 9%

Chicago Blower 6%


Feeders

K Tron 29%

Acrison 16%

Schenck AccuRate 9%

Flexicon 5%


Filtration Systems

Pall 15%

Millipore 11%

Siemens (U.S. Filter) 8%

Filter Specialties, Inc. 5%


Flow Instrumentation

Emerson Process Management 59%

Endress+Hauser 7%


Heat Exchangers

Alfa Laval 21%

Tranter 7%

ITT 6%

APV 5%


Heat Transfer Fluids

Dow 61%

Solutia 21%


Infrared Thermography Equipment

FLIR 31%

Fluke 30%


Instrument Calibration Systems

Fluke 28%

Emerson Process Management 14%


Level Instrumentation

Emerson Process Management 41%

Endress+Hauser 11%

Ohmart Vega 6%

Magnetrol 5%

Lubricants

ExxonMobil 25%

Shell 15%

Royal Purple 11%

Lubrizol 7%

Chevron 6%

Dow 5%


Mixing Systems

SPX Process Equipment 35%

Chemineer 20%

Philadelphia 5%


Motors

Baldor 51%

GE 14%

Siemens 12%


Pipe/Tubing/Fittings

Swagelok 40%

Parker 12%


Plant Design Software

Autodesk 24%

AspenTech 22%

Intergraph 10%


Positive Displacement Pumps

Viking 18%

Moyno 8%

Milton Roy 7%

SPX Process Equipment 7%

Wilden 5%


Pressure Instrumentation

Emerson Process Management 51%

Ashcroft 8%

Honeywell 5%


Process Analyzers

Emerson Process Management 22%

ABB 15%

Siemens 14%


Process Automation Systems

Emerson Process Management 35%

Rockwell Automation 17%

Honeywell 15%

Siemens 7%

Invensys 7%

ABB 6%

Process Simulation Software

AspenTech 48%

Honeywell 8%

ChemStations 8%


Seals

John Crane 46%

Flowserve 10%

Chesterton 9%


Spray Nozzles

Spray Systems 43%

Bete 27%

Sprayco 7%


Tanks & Vessels

Mueller 7%

Pfaudler 6%


Temperature Instrumentation

Emerson Process Management 50%

Omega 10%


Vacuum Systems

Nash_Elmo 22%

Busch 15%

Sihi 11%

Graham 8%


Valves & Actuators

Emerson Process Management 35%

Neles-Jamesbury 7%

Flowserve 6%


Variable Speed Drives

Rockwell Automation 34%

ABB 16%

Toshiba 7%

Siemens 7%

GE 5%


Vibration Monitoring Equipment

GE (Bently Nevada) 56%

Emerson Process Management 13%

IRD 5%


Water Treatment Systems

GE 24%

Nalco 16%

Siemens 14%

Calgon 6%


Weighing Systems

Mettler Toledo 58%

Hardy Instruments 5%